AintSoBad

Linda,
I strongly agree with Sandra.
These reports are very difficult to hear, or read, but I too think that doctor was really on your side!
I remember reading Dr. Schwartzman's testimony for me (transcript of his videotaped deposition). I too, was in tears. (It was "otherworldly", I couldn't believe I was reading about myself!)
But, without it, I wouldn't have been awarded what I was.
And, I'm fairly certain, that I, Dr S. and my Attorney, were a "team" that really upset the insurance industry, and put RSD on their "Radar".

(I don't know if you recall the story of me actually meeting, the adjuster who had to write my check, at a tiki bar in the Keys), he told me that the entire industry is freaked out by this disease, and my award! As well they should be.

They know they can't win, but still, they use dirty tactics.
This doctor really covered you.
Let God do the rest.

I wish you the best, and pray for your comfort..

Pete

nancyinLA

so sorry ur heart hurts so badly. how well i'm learning how little people know about RSD! even some of the quacks that W.C. sends me to - do they ever read current medical info? i don't have full body, so i really send u good thoughts & i have u in my prayers. this has been a cryin' day 4 me. take care of urself...... thinkin' of ya.

__________________
May you always be overwhelmed by the
Grace of God rather than by the cares of life!

CRPSbe

I am so sorry that it didn't go well at all and that more can't be done for you as far as treatment goes. Please hang in there and don't give up despite this terrible ordeal.

__________________
All the best, Marleen
=====================
Work related (car) accident September 21, 1995, consequences:
- chondromalacia patellae both knees
- RSD both legs (late diagnosis, almost 3 years into RSD) & spread to arms/hands as of 2008
Meds: Gabapentin 2700mg - Transtec 70µg - Temgesic sublingual - Epsipam

fmichael

Dear Dew -

The one thing I have to focus on is when you said:

I was dx 15 months out from initial injury. Too late for blocks, or anything!

I'm pleased to report that there are still good treatment options available. Check out for one, Schwartzman RJ, Alexander GM, Grothusen JR, Paylor T, Reichenberger E, Perreault M, Outpatient intravenous ketamine for the treatment of complex regional pain syndrome: A double-blind placebo controlled study, Pain 2009, in press, free full text at http://www.rsds.org/2/library/articl...n_Pain2009.pdf :

a b s t r a c t
Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) is a severe chronic pain condition that most often develops following trauma. The pathophysiology of CRPS is not known but both clinical and experimental evidence demonstrate the important of the NMDA receptor and glial activation in its induction and maintenance. Ketamine is the most potent clinically available safe NMDA antagonist that has a well established role in the treatment of acute and chronic pain. This randomized double-blind placebo controlled trial was designed to evaluate the effectiveness of intravenous ketamine in the treatment of CRPS. Before treatment, after informed consent was obtained, each subject was randomized into a ketamine or a placebo infusion group. Study subjects were evaluated for at least 2 weeks prior to treatment and for 3 months following treatment. All subjects were infused intravenously with normal saline with or without ketamine for 4 h (25 ml/h) daily for 10 days. The maximum ketamine infusion rate was 0.35 mg/kg/h, not to exceed 25 g/h over a 4 h period. Subjects in both the ketamine and placebo groups were administered clonidine and versed. This study showed that intravenous ketamine administered in an outpatient setting resulted in statistically significant (p < 0.05) reductions in many pain parameters. It also showed that subjects in our placebo group demonstrated no treatment effect in any parameter. The results of this study warrant a larger randomized placebo controlled trial using higher doses of ketamine and a longer follow-up period.

2009 International Association for the Study of Pain. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

And while, in the study's conclusion, the authors note that among its limitations were the "nonstratification of patients either by length of time with the illness or by the temperature of the affected area," it bears noting that not only was the sole inclusion criteria, for any patient with a confirmed a diagnosis of CRPS "whose condition was intractable for a minimum of 6 months and had failed at least three of the following therapies; nerve blocks, opioid analgesics, non-opioid analgesics, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, anti-seizure medications, antidepressants, muscle relaxants or physical therapy[,']" but, in conjuntion with another point, they make the following observation:

There were no significant differences between those patients with a shorter duration of CRPS (11 patients with an average length of illness of 2.6 years and a range of 0.8–4.2 years) and longstanding patients (8 patients with an average length of illness of 12.2 years and a range of 6.8–20 years). [Para. 4.2]

In other words, not only did they make no effort whatsoever to cherry-pick their subjects based upon duration of disease, but looking at the spread of patients, someone with only 15 months of the disease looks like a newbie!

And as noted in the earlier thread on this piece, Ketamine, the article http://neurotalk.psychcentral.com/thread104838.html, it's just this kind of double blind placebo controlled study (or perhaps a larger one with NIH funding behind it, now that this one has crossed the threshold) that is going to make the WC insurance companies of the world finally pay for this treatment!

And even without ketamine, have you considered Methadone or Zometa? Methadone is surely covered by WC and has the unique advantage (in addition to being a powerful analgesic) of being an NDMA-receptor antagonist: which is to say that it goes to the heart of the beast. Just be sure to get something prescribed by your doctor to keep your GI system moving while you're on it.

And there are yet more things out there, for now considered experimental, including the very interesting work Michael Stanton-Hicks, MD is doing with "high dose" Prialt, to say nothing of my old favorite, before I found out that California law restricts its use only to certain defined psychiatric diagnoses: right unilateral electroconvulsive therapy.

Finally, just in terms of learning how to drop your resistance to the pain and accept it as just another sensation for the time being, I cannot begin to tell you what a life altering experience I had - about a year into my diagnosis - when a really good pain psychologist suggested that I take an MBSR class. (Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction.) The program has been run out of the Univ. of Mass. Med School for over 30 years (started by one Jon Kabot-Zin, PhD. - an interesting Google search). I've heard Jon speak at UCLA (a packed-hall) and it's clear that one of the origional and continuing central thrusts of the program has been assisting people in chronic pain. And it works! It's built around a 2 and 1/2 hour class that meet one day a week for eight weeks, with a strong emphasis on a daily practice of meditation and yoga (wonderful for proprioceptive skills) concluding with a day long retreat/program. For those of us who don't live near its Worcester MA base of operations, where teachers are trained and classes are freely provided to students, the cost is roughly $500, depending on the area. Here's the homepage, along with a search engine that let's anyone find one of its trained teachers in their area. (Full disclosure: my MBSR teacher 7 years ago is one of my best friends today.)
http://www.umassmed.edu/Content.aspx...d&itemid=41254

So hang in there and be of good cheer,
Mike

cindi1965

((((DEW)))

It's like "wow, how can drs. be so uncaring?" You know almost all of us have been through so much that it takes everything we have to get by, but if we all read each other's story's we are strong somewhere inside. I just don't know what else to say, but we are all here for you.....gentle, gentle hugs and prayers from me

Cindi

finz

I'm sorry this is such a tough spell for you right now Dew.

Please do what you can to stay on top of your pain levels. I know when mine is soaring, I'm not able to deal with stress, get very weepy, and take a pessimistic view. Times like right now, when it is controlled, I can see what I do have to liuve for and look forward to.

Hockey

Hey Dew,

Sandel is right, that medical report is going to help your legal case. The other side's doc probably won't even touch you at all because he will be trying NOT to find things.

Still, please don't come away from this thinking you are a person of no value. That's not true - and I don't even think the doctor thought that. Your lawyer picked him because they both know, that short of a brutally frank assessment, WC will declare you fit for the Olympics.

There's no humanity in this system, but it's the one you're stuck with. This nonsense won't last forever.

Breezy55

Dew,I am so sorry to hear the way that you were treated! Tear's are just a part of the human experience if there were no limitations to overcome. I felt the same way that you did when I was just in the hospital for the last 3 weeks. Every time I woud start to cry there was this nurse that would come into my room. Instead of being understanding she would just look at me and say(You know the more you cry the more your pain is going to go up) Then she would just walk out and not look back! This world is filled with people that just don't understand what we are dealing with! At times they sure can be quite cold hearted.We are all here for you! I also know that you have a loving husband that is there fighting for you also! I know that this dx is not fair! Please hang in there,we are all here for you! Take Care My Friend! Breezy

SandyRI

You and I are so similar - we are close in age (I am 48), we were injured around the same time (I was hurt on 11/1/06) and I had 2 surgeries trying to get better (4/07 and 5/08) with horrific PT after each. The differeince is that I hurt my shoulder and you hurt your knee. I likely had RSD after my 1st surgery and my surgeon suspected it because of the continual anesthesia he left in me after the 2nd surgery.

Anyway - I've had lots of trigger point injections, blocks and 3 lidocaine infusions and I don't know that they changed anything for me on a long term basis. My RSD did spread after the trigger points to my neck and my head and I have truly suffered a LOT with severe head pain. Plus I can't lie down or rest on the back of my head. Ever. Not in bed, not in a car, not in a lounge chair to watch TV. It really stinks. I've also had spread lately to my left hip (making sleep almost impossible) and my face, which spasms in the cold windy air when I walk a lot ouside with my dog.

The best treatment so far for me has been meds. When my head hurts horribly I take my meds and try to relax until they kick in.

I have fought a lot to get treatments for myself because I still see myself returning to work early next year. That is why I am currently pursuing ketamine. I don't have approval from WC for it yet. I am not ready to file for SSDI, nor can I afford it. I still have two children to educate and the RI tax burden for families is outrageous - my property taxes alone would likely use up half my check.

The crying spells I so understand, been there, done that. I'm really sorry for your pain - both physical and emotional. When I started to cry a lot last summer I finally found a therapist to talk to and I think it has helped. I think it is great that you have one forever. How about a PT, though? Wouldn't that help also?

Please take care.

XOXOX Sandy

Imahotep

When I got my social security determination I just couldn't believe how depressing it was. Here this was what I'd been saying pretty much for years but seeing it in print and knowing it's probably never going to change are two different things.

There should be a great deal more transparency with the insurance companies in what they do cover and what they don't regarding this condition. There should be more transparency with possible courses of action and treatment. There should be more transparency with prognoses right from the get go. People shouldn't be denied treatment because they don't know the situation. They shouldn't be denied treatment bacause workers compensation is set up the way it is.

RSD might frighten the insurance industry but what the hell do they think it's doing to us and our lives.

Maybe if this weren't usiually brushed under the carpet there would be a far better protocol that would result in more good outcomes rather than what we have now. Imagine if most people got treatment in the first few hours of onset!! I have to believe this disease will be licked only when it's accepted as a possible consequence of nearly any traumatic injury.